Lessons from Kalwa v. The King (2025 TCC 89): Why Reporting Capital Gains Matters?

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________

A recent Tax Court of Canada decision, Kalwa v. The King (2025 TCC 89), serves as a reminder of the high stakes involved when taxpayers fail to properly report capital gains.

The Case at a Glance

Mr. Kalwa’s 2016 tax return was reassessed by the CRA in September 2019. The reassessment determined he had failed to report $150,051 in capital gains. In addition to the tax owing, the CRA imposed penalties under subsection 163(2) of the Income Tax Act for gross negligence.

Kalwa appealed to the Tax Court, arguing that the penalties were unjustified and that the reassessment was flawed.

What the Court Considered

The Court focused on two main questions:

1. Was the reassessment valid?
   • Normally, the CRA has a limited time to reassess returns, but if there’s a misrepresentation due to neglect, carelessness, or wilful default, they can reassess beyond that window. The Court found the unreported gains were significant enough to justify the reassessment.
2. Were penalties appropriate?
   • Penalties under subsection 163(2) require proof that the taxpayer acted knowingly or with gross negligence. After reviewing the evidence, the Court agreed with the CRA that the omission amounted to at least gross negligence, so penalties applied.

Key Takeaways

This case highlights some important lessons for Canadian taxpayers:

• Report everything: All capital gains—whether from property, securities, or investments—must be reported. The CRA has strong data-matching tools to detect omissions.
• Documentation is key: Keep records of purchase and sale prices, legal fees, and other costs to support your reporting.
• Penalties are severe: Subsection 163(2) penalties can equal 50% of the understated tax, plus interest.
• Appeals are possible but difficult: The burden of proof lies with the taxpayer, and courts expect careful, accurate filing.

Why It Matters

With the CRA placing greater focus on real estate transactions and investment income, cases like Kalwa show how even one missed disclosure can trigger years of dispute and significant penalties.

Final Thoughts

Kalwa v. The King (2025 TCC 89) reinforces the importance of diligence and accuracy in tax reporting. Unreported capital gains not only attract tax reassessments but can also lead to substantial penalties for gross negligence.

👉 If you are facing a CRA reassessment or worried about unreported gains, consult a tax professional early. Proactive advice can help you avoid costly disputes and protect your financial peace of mind.